RESOLVING THE LEDGER
This is one outlet's own report from The A.V. Club — the article as it was filed. Other outlets are covering the same event; open the full story to compare every source side by side.
See the full story · 2 sourcesYou could think up a less threatening name for a serial child killer than The Whisper Man, but few others would so aptly capture the experience of watching this barely-there thriller. You can hear it alright, but that only makes its sometimes amusing lack of substance more legible. Produced by the Russo brothers for Netflix—which has become a far more threatening phrase than anything uttered by this film’s sociopaths— The Whisper Man is grayer than The Gray Man and more obvious than The Snowman , who gives Mister Police all the clues.
Here, all the clues are given to the audience, while the police mostly seem like they’re recovering from a collective head injury. Under the command of The Rule Of Jenny Pen director James Ashcroft, a trio of interconnected characters search for a murderer who’s started snatching kids in the same fashion as a prior killer, caught decades ago. There’s Amanda (Michelle Monaghan), the detective assigned to the current case; widowed author Tom (Adam Scott), whose son Jake (Acston Luca Porto) gets snatched as soon as they move back Tom’s New Jersey hometown; and retired detective Pete (Robert De Niro), the initial Whisper Man investigator and Tom’s estranged dad, called back up for one more job—and this time, it’s personal.
The writerly web linking everyone and everything is overt, with utilitarian dialogue that whacks backstory and murder victims with the same bluntness. You won’t ever be confused, not about the culprit (who lures lonely kids outside by whispering to them through their windows and/or mail slots) and not about whether Tom’s wife is dead. But since the film condenses Alex North’s novel into 105 pre-credits minutes, there’s just not a lot of time to set up a multigenerational cat-and-mouse chase that frequently detours into strained paternal relationships.
Attempting to do so anyway, where the narrative numbers are nearly visible under the paint in every scene, traps a capable cast in a contrived story. There’s not much room to build suspense when you’ve also got to fit in Jake’s imaginary friend (it doesn’t matter), a clear red herring suspect, and a silly little Whisper Man rhyme, akin to those that summon demons like The Bye Bye Man in schlocky horror movies. And that’s not even mentioning what might be the first-ever case of Chekhov’s leaking roof. Actually there’s a lot of heavy lifting done by the ceilings in this film, as, in a representative example of The Whisper Man ‘s depth of insight, an oft-plastered-over crack stands in for the fractured relationship between Pete and Tom.
Talking about ceilings is only a degree or so off from describing The Whisper Man as watching paint dry, which would give the false impression that anything in the film had color. Its bleak color palette is as generic and predictable as the plot, and as frustrating as the protagonists’ actions. One can’t expect a film character to act perfectly rationally, but Tom, wandering about in his desaturated world, seems to simply forget about some major breaches of home security and an uncovered secret room in his new basement. Cynically, it can feel like he’s designed to be yelled at from the comfort of the living room couch. More realistically, it seems like there’s a lot of movie missing around him.
What’s left is a couple run-ins with creeps, including the incarcerated Whisper Man himself (Michael Keaton, squirrely as ever) and a cheeseball murderabilia collector caricatured by Hamish Linklater. Every once in a while, Scott will say “The Whisper Man” out loud and we’ll all have a good laugh. One scene, where he shouts it over and over again, is more fun than the rest of the movie combined. Though Monaghan is in serviceable cop procedural mode and De Niro isn’t as worn-out as he could be, it’s really just Owen Teague, who does a passable Anthony Perkins bit, who comes out looking ok. The rest—from the half-hearted investigation to the truly sad action climax (Who can be expected to pretend that 83-year-old Robert De Niro is fistfighting anyone?)—is like trying to watch a more competent drama over a bad internet connection, everything chugging along in a pixelated 144p.
The Whisper Man never finds even the B-movie thrills of a similarly close-to-home child-abduction drama like Prisoners , instead flipping through its airport novel plot and discarding it as such without much thought. More disheartening, it never allows its capable cast any room to work within the intensity that comes with the territory, reducing all their emotions to a dull murmur.
Director: James Ashcroft
Writer: Ben Jacoby, Chase Palmer
Starring: Robert De Niro, Michelle Monaghan, Adam Scott, Michael Keaton, Hamish Linklater, Owen Teague
Release Date: August 28, 2026 (Netflix)
AIPROPX is an independent multi-source news index — we track, compare, and connect coverage from across the web into one place you won't find anywhere else.