RESOLVING THE LEDGER
This is one outlet's own report from Yahoo Sports — the article as it was filed. Other outlets are covering the same event; open the full story to compare every source side by side.
See the full story · 4 sources
LIV Golf 1.0 — the era of big talk and bigger paychecks — is over. Whatever comes next for the breakaway tour, cut loose by Saudi Arabian funding and now on the hunt for outside investment, the days of "Golf But Louder" are done.
Without a doubt, LIV fundamentally changed the structure of men's professional golf, forcing the PGA Tour into reworking its entire structure, schedule and financial model. LIV altered the professional arcs of some of the game's greatest players, gave others the opportunity to destroy their own reputations, and provided a pathway back to prominence for the once-lost Anthony Kim. LIV also brought the concept of sportswashing into the mainstream of the American sports conversation, forcing sports fans to decide just how much politics they were willing to accept with their sports.
That's a hell of an impact in just a few short years, but that also leads into another LIV lesson: the impossibility of competing with the established American sports framework. Even a league funded by bottomless oil wealth ultimately couldn't compete with a vulnerable legacy organization.
So what does that mean? Competing with the PGA Tour is a lost cause for LIV, so coexistence is now the only path forward. And if LIV is going to survive and thrive in the years to come, version 2.0 will need to learn from the mistakes of its predecessor. And oh, are there plenty of lessons to learn.
Golf, but humbler
LIV Golf fired off the tee in 2021 with swagger, attitude and arrogance, largely mirroring the personality of firebrand Greg Norman. Longtime PGA Tour antagonists like Norman and Phil Mickelson spoke openly (and in court filings) of wanting to upend the Tour's entire business model, torching the very house in which they'd grown wealthy. That didn't sit well with Tour traditionalists, and the badass playacting came off as more silly than intimidating. You're smacking a little white ball around a field, gentlemen. Let's not pretend this is armed combat.
Know your role
If the PGA Tour-LIV battle was a Ryder Cup, LIV would have scored some early Friday upsets, but the Tour found its footing by Saturday, and the outcome was never in doubt on Sunday. That doesn't mean LIV deserves to vanish, but it does mean LIV needs to understand its new role in golf's ecosystem. There's room and opportunity for a truly international tour, one which doesn't center on the United States. LIV can serve a worldwide golf-starved audience, even if that means sacrificing some face domestically.
Target the PGA Tour's inefficiencies
The Tour's intense focus on American markets represents a massive opportunity for LIV Golf. More to the point, the Tour's intense focus on its best players and marquee sites presents a clear path for LIV. Domestically, LIV can target markets left behind in the PGA Tour's grand new have-and-have-not two-track plan for both players and tournament venues. And with relations warming between the two Tours — or, at least, the Tour viewing LIV as much less of a threat — there's the opportunity to develop a more viable pathway between the two tours. A lower-track PGA Tour player might find more earning opportunity on LIV, and now that LIV's existential threat is done, the Tour ought to consider opening those gates a little wider. Though the comparison isn't exact, both NASCAR and the WNBA allow their top-tier competitors to participate in other, lower leagues. An LIV-PGA crossover is logistically possible, it's just a question of the will to do so.
Get those OWGR points
LIV's key selling point for younger players had been its massive paychecks. With that likely gone, LIV will need to demonstrate that it's a viable route to the majors — the one true benchmark for success in the game today, over and above even the PGA Tour. LIV has made steps in this direction, getting some small sums of Official World Golf Ranking points and receiving open acknowledgement from Augusta National chairman Fred Ridley at this year's Masters. LIV needs to do whatever's necessary to get as many points as possible for its competitors, and if that means more harsh relegation for underperforming players, so be it. LIV 2.0 needs to demonstrate that it's a viable league all on its own, not as some screw-you alternative to the PGA Tour.
Don't try so hard
Right from the jump, LIV attempted to position itself as a fully formed, end-to-end league of teams, colors, iconography and legacy. As with everything LIV did, that's understandable — you don't carve out space for yourself by asking politely — but LIV's attempts at identity creation don't read as rebellious, they feel like theater kids gone wild:
Flash Mob breaks out on first tee before start of #LIVGolf London pic.twitter.com/RVmXpB9S9g
— Mike McAllister (@thegolfeditor) July 7, 2023
Wanting to cut against the staid, starchy, stodgy tradition of golf is admirable; attempting it through choreographed dance and desperate attempts at memes ain't the right way to go. Playing golf and hanging at tournaments are both cool enough in themselves without trying to make a viral moment out of thin air.
Go West … and East
LIV's proponents, whether internally or on social media, tend to puff up even the slightest bit of good news. But it's indisputable that, by any measure, LIV's tournaments in South Africa, Australia and South Korea have been significant successes. Ratings and attendance in the United States, not so much. That would seem to strongly suggest that LIV's future lies beyond the boundaries of America. Believe it or not, there are nations out there, and sponsors too, who are both interested in golf and also have nothing whatsoever to do with the United States. Really. It's true.
Bryson yes, Rahm no
Although the identity of LIV's mysteriou...
AIPROPX is an independent multi-source news index — we track, compare, and connect coverage from across the web into one place you won't find anywhere else.