RESOLVING THE LEDGER
This is one outlet's own report from Yahoo Sports — the article as it was filed. Other outlets are covering the same event; open the full story to compare every source side by side.
See the full story · 1 sources
Photo by Elsa/Getty Images
Back in 2021, long before current transgender debates took over sports media, Cathy Engelbert made the WNBA’s stance clear.
The WNBA debate continues over whether biological men should be allowed to compete in the league.
But the conversation wasn’t always this tense. Back in 2021, Layshia Clarendon made history as the league’s first openly trans and non-binary player. Because Clarendon was a biological woman competing in a women’s league, their transition involved top surgery without altering physical capabilities or competitive fairness, showing how inclusion can be achieved.
Of course, it is complete opposite ends of the spectrum, but it’s interesting to dive into the different reactions and perspectives in the two situations.
Cathy Engelbert was fully supportive of Layshia Clarendon
WNBA Commissioner Cathy Engelbert has faced backlash over her handling of the transgender eligibility debate, with critics faulting her for a lack of clear policy definitions in the collective bargaining agreement.
People have accused the league of dodging decisive standards, leaving the sport vulnerable to culture-war stunts and escalating public conflict.
However, it was a straightforward reaction when she found out about Layshia Clarendon’s transition back in 2021.
She said: “We are so proud that Layshia is part of the WNBA and we know that their (Layshia uses they/them pronouns) voice and continued advocacy will not only support and help honor and uplift many other non-binary and trans people, but also encourage empathy and understanding for the community across all levels of sport.”
When it comes to the current male debate, anger toward Cathy Engelbert stems from her refusal to take a firm stand.
You could argue she could put the controversy to rest by updating policy language to explicitly protect biological women. Instead, her silence and vague responses suggest she cannot even clearly define the league’s baseline criteria herself.
Enes Kanter has already issued an ultimatum to the WNBA that he will walk away if they simply define a woman, so what’s the hold up?
The WNBA already had an openly trans player long before the Enes Kanter debate
WNBA given a new nickname following treatment of Caitlin Clark
Angel Reese explains exactly what DeWanna Bonner will bring to the Atlanta Dream
AIPROPX is an independent multi-source news index — we track, compare, and connect coverage from across the web into one place you won't find anywhere else.