RESOLVING THE LEDGER
This is one outlet's own report from CoinDesk — the article as it was filed. Other outlets are covering the same event; open the full story to compare every source side by side.
See the full story · 1 sources
The arguments is based on economics. Each of the six deployments now generate less than $5,000 a quarter. Metis, Soneium and Aptos bring in under $1,000 each, according to the proposal. That does not cover the cost of running them, which includes maintaining price feeds, liquidation systems and monitoring for each market.
For context, Aave’s Ethereum mainnet deployment generates more than $142 million a year and Base about $4.7 million, while Metis produces roughly $3,000.
Deposits have collapsed across all six over six months. Soneium fell 95%, available liquidity on Aptos dropped 94%, zkSync declined 88% to about $844,000, Scroll fell 86% to roughly $2 million, Metis dropped 79%, and Sonic, the largest of the group, fell 74% to just under $8 million.
The six hold a cominbed $13 million in deposits against Aave’s roughly $14 billion across 23 chains, DefiLlama data shows, or under 1% of the protocol’s assets.
Aave’s borrowers paid about $888 million in interest over the past year, but almost all of it flows straight back out to the people who supplied the money. Aave itself kept roughly $117 million, according to DefiLlama, or about 13 cents of every dollar collected. The quarterly accounts show the same split. Of $156 million in gross revenue in the second quarter.
The numbers stop being marginal and become trivial when applied to six chains. Each generates under $5,000 a quarter in revenue, and Metis, Soneium and Aptos bring in less than $1,000 each. At Aave’s usual take, the protocol’s own share of a $5,000 quarter is a few hundred dollars. Metis, on those terms, is worth roughly the price of a dinner.
The timing is explained by the bottom line, which is falling. Gross revenue dropped from $198 million in the first quarter to $156 million in the second, a decline of a fifth. Third-quarter figures are one month old and running well below that pace, with liquidation fees the clearest casualty, down from $27 million in the second quarter to under $200,000 so far.
Existing positions would not be forcibly closed. The markets would be frozen to new deposits, borrowing and collateral use, with supply and borrowing limits cut to a single token, 99% of borrower interest routed to Aave’s treasury and a 5% base borrowing rate introduced, making it expensive enough to stay that remaining users leave on their own.
The proposal could be seen as the logical conclusion of Aave’s new direction that was set out months ago. In December, the Aave Chan Initiative proposed rolling back deployments on zkSync, Metis and Soneium as having “proven to lack product market fit,” and pushed a rule requiring any future deployment to commit to at least $2 million in annual revenue.
Aave has cast the cleanup as risk reduction as much as cost-cutting: one factor overlaps the other.
1 Crypto for Advisors: Is the Clarity Act dead? 21 minutes ago 2 CME's Duffy warns an overlooked tax risk looms over U.S. perpetual futures 49 minutes ago 3 JPMorgan says fading Clarity Act odds weigh on crypto outlook 1 hour ago 4 Institutional crypto trading hits a record 72% as Wall Street calms crypto's wild swings 1 hour ago 5 Ethereum enters its second decade after a year of upheaval at the foundation 1 hour ago 6 Fake staking site drains $8.5 million in XRP from dozens of investors promising easy yield 1 hour ago 7 Telegram faces terror-related legal action in Australia one day after founder is charged by Russia 3 hours ago 8 Bitcoin ETFs on track for the smallest monthly inflows ever 4 hours ago 9 South Korea plans to tax crypto gains over $1,740 as political battle moves to parliament 4 hours ago 10 Crypto's resilience tested as oil rises after Iran strikes, Fed signals rates could still rise 4 hours ago Latest Research Anvil: The Missing Collateral Layer Anvil: The Missing Collateral Layer Anvil is a shared on-chain collateral layer built on a programmable letter of credit: reserve assets as a guarantee -no loan, no interest, keep custody & yield.
Anvil is a shared on-chain collateral layer built on a programmable letter of credit: reserve assets as a guarantee -no loan, no interest, keep custody & yield.
AIPROPX is an independent multi-source news index — we track, compare, and connect coverage from across the web into one place you won't find anywhere else.