RESOLVING THE LEDGER
This is one outlet's own report from Time — the article as it was filed. Other outlets are covering the same event; open the full story to compare every source side by side.
See the full story · 1 sources.png%3Fbranch%3Dproduction)
—Photo-Illustration by TIME (Source Image: AnnaStills/Getty Images)
Most people know the rule: Never comment on another person's body. People experiencing weight loss often find themselves fielding comments regardless. And if they have an eating disorder, both the comments and the silence can fuel it in different ways.
Dr. Jennifer L. Gaudiani, an internist in Denver who specializes in eating disorders, says patients tell her some version of the same thing all the time: “Nobody said a word while I disappeared, and it messed with my head.”
“The actual comment or the absence of the comment are both instantly absorbed and processed in ways that can be really undermining and painful,” she says. “If somebody says something positive, the eating disorder goes, ‘Well, I'm clearly not sick enough to warrant anyone's concern, and my therapist must be wrong, because people keep telling me I look good,’” Gaudiani says. “And if it's the other direction, then the eating disorder is like, ‘Oh my gosh, kick it into gear. You gotta really go harder.’”
That leaves anyone who’s genuinely concerned in a difficult position: Say the wrong thing, and you could make things worse; say nothing, and your silence might say something you never intended. The good news is that there’s a way to have this conversation that feels like care rather than surveillance or judgment—and clinicians who navigate this territory for a living have a clear sense of what to say.
When to say something about someone's weight loss
There isn’t a magic number that tells you when it’s time to speak up. No amount of weight loss automatically calls for a conversation, says Dr. Evelyn Attia, a psychiatrist and director of the Center for Eating Disorders at New York-Presbyterian Hospital—but you also don’t need to wait until someone looks alarmingly thin. “Clinically significant eating disorders can occur in individuals across all shapes and sizes,” she says. Often, the people closest to someone can tell when something simply feels off, and that instinct is worth listening to.
You don’t have to know exactly what’s going on before you say something. People often get stuck waiting for certainty, says Francesca Emma, a therapist in Long Island who specializes in eating disorders and body image. You’re not trying to diagnose the person; you’re letting them know you’ve noticed a change and are there to support them. If you hold out until you feel completely sure—or completely comfortable—you may never bring it up.
The most useful clues are often physical and behavioral, not visual, Attia says. Maybe your friend has become dizzy, pale, or short of breath more often, or has fainted without a clear medical explanation. Or perhaps the change shows up around food: They used to love going out to dinner, and now they turn down every invitation that involves eating. Foods they once enjoyed are suddenly off-limits. Those shifts—not the size of their body—deserve your attention.
None of this means every drop in weight calls for a heart-to-heart. People lose weight for all sorts of reasons—a new medication, an illness, grief, stress, or changes they’re making with a doctor. “That's not what we're talking about here,” Attia says. “We're talking about medically significant nutritional change.” The distinction is whether weight loss is simply something you’ve noticed, or one piece of a larger pattern that makes you worry about your friend’s health.
What to say to someone you're worried about
Once you’ve decided to speak up, your first instinct might be to name the most obvious thing: the weight loss. Try not to. Vanessa Scaringi, a psychologist and eating disorder specialist in Cincinnati, says clinicians often steer families toward talking about behaviors instead: the skipped book club, the lunch that keeps coming home uneaten, the friend who’s stopped showing up anywhere food might be served. “Behaviors are safer,” she says.
That’s partly because a comment about someone’s body rarely lands as intended. “It could shut someone down,” Scaringi says. Worse, it might register as praise. “Sometimes it actually feeds the eating disorder, where it's like, ‘Oh, mission accomplished.’”
But avoiding comments about weight doesn’t mean being so vague that the person has no idea what you’re talking about. Point to something specific and observable, Scaringi suggests: “You haven’t come to anything involving food in two months” or “You seem much more rigid about eating than you used to be.” Emma recommends leading with curiosity rather than a conclusion: “I’ve noticed some changes, and I’m wondering how you’re doing,” as opposed to “I think you have an eating disorder.” The first opens a conversation, while the second can feel like an accusation or diagnosis.
Before you begin, examine your own motives. Eating disorders can carry what Scaringi calls a whiff of the salacious, and feeling riveted by someone’s changing body isn’t the same as caring about their well-being. Ask yourself: “Am I bringing this up because I’m genuinely worried about this person, or because I’m curious about what’s happening?” If the answer is merely curiosity, keep it to yourself.
How to start the conversation
Don’t spring this conversation on someone over dinner—or anywhere other people might overhear. Find a private moment when neither of you is rushing out the door or already upset. Then ask permission before going any further. Gaudiani’s go-to opener sounds something like this: “I want to say something to you that comes from a place of deep care and some concern, and it might be a little hard to hear. I wonder if you're in a space where we could have a brief, meaningful conversation.”
The question isn’t a formality. “Consent is important at every step,” Gaudiani says. It gives the person a moment to decide whether they’re ready to hear you—and signals that they’re not about to be ambushed.
If they say yes, say what you came to say—and then stop. Gaudiani is more comfortable than...
AIPROPX is an independent multi-source news index — we track, compare, and connect coverage from across the web into one place you won't find anywhere else.