Darkly comical': Cricket world baffled as Pakistan drop 'best bowler' Mohammad Abbas for WI 2nd Test over 'conditions

'Darkly comical': Cricket world baffled as Pakistan drop 'best bowler' Mohammad Abbas for WI 2nd Test over 'conditions' originally appeared on Cricket News .

Add Cricket News as a Preferred Source by clicking here .

KEY TAKEAWAYS:

Pakistan dropped Mohammad Abbas for the second Test despite his eight wickets, including a five-wicket haul in the first Test match of the series.

Babar Azam explained the omission was down to conditions at the Port of Spain.

The decision baffled fans and pundits, with debutant Ubaid Shah coming in.

Cricket world baffled as Pakistan drop 'best bowler' Mohammad Abbas

Pakistan have once again left the cricketing world scratching its head, dropping their standout bowler Mohammad Abbas for the second Test against West Indies. The seamer had been comfortably the visitors' best performer in the opening match, making his omission one of the more baffling selection calls of recent times.

Abbas claimed eight wickets in the first Test at Tarouba, including a five-wicket haul, as Pakistan slipped to a 90-run defeat. Yet rather than building the attack around him for the series decider at Port of Spain, the management chose to leave him out entirely, handing a debut to fast bowler Ubaid Shah instead.

Captain Babar Azam sought to justify the move on tactical grounds, but the explanation did little to quell the disbelief that greeted the team sheet.

Pakistan Test captain Babar Azam points to conditions

Babar was direct in attributing the decision to the surface. As reported by ESPNcricinfo , the captain said Abbas's omission was down to conditions, with Pakistan making four changes in all for the fixture at Queen's Park Oval.

Mohammad Abbas, who claimed eight wickets in the first Test against West Indies, including a five-wicket haul, misses out on the second Test 👀 Pakistan captain Babar Azam said the omission was "down to the conditions" Abbas is the first Pakistan bowler since Ehteshamuddin on… pic.twitter.com/57yDDLYzFl

— Cricinfo (@cricinfo) August 2, 2026 The rationale struck many as thin given the numbers involved. ESPNcricinfo noted that Abbas became the first Pakistan bowler since Ehteshamuddin on the 1979-80 tour of India to be left out immediately after taking a five-wicket haul in the same Test series, a statistic that underlined the rarity of the call.

The early signs did little to vindicate the decision, with debutant Ubaid Shah proving expensive as he conceded 30 in four overs while West Indies made a brisk start.

MORE: No Sooryavanshi: DK picks India squad for 2027 ODI World Cup, two surprise inclusions

A decision that drew widespread ridicule

The reaction across social media was swift and scathing. Former Pakistan cricketer Bazid Khan captured the incredulity, writing , "Abbass dropped 🤯! Playing with 5 specialist bowlers didn't last long."

Abbass dropped 🤯! Playing with 5 specialist bowlers didn’t last long

— Bazid Khan (@bazidkhan81) August 2, 2026 Others shared this confusion. One Pakistan supporter questioned if the conditions really warranted his dropping.  "What conditions does Abbas not work in exactly?  Perhaps any conditions that involve Pak cricket setups of the last decade," they wrote .

What conditions does Abbas not work in exactly? Perhaps any conditions that involve Pak cricket setups of the last decade. pic.twitter.com/Yhz9i3YvEM

— Osman Samiuddin (@OsmanSamiuddin) August 2, 2026 Meanwhile another fan lamented , "Abbas dropped while in red hot form. PCB are the own goal kings." They chose humour but the comparison does match with that the PCB are doing with their own selection decisions.  The irony was not lost on close watchers of Pakistan cricket.

Abbas dropped while in red hot form. PCB are the own goal kings 👑

— Ali Khan Tareen (@aliktareen) August 2, 2026 Another viewer wrote sarcastically , "Something darkly comical about Mohammad Abbas, who called on the ICC last week for Pak to be given more Tests (something not within the ICC's remit), being dropped by his own board from one of the Tests Pak are actually playing, after he was Pak's best bowler in the first Test."

Something darkly comical about Mohammad Abbas, who called on the ICC last week for Pak to be given more Tests (something not within the ICC's remit), being dropped by his own board from one of the Tests Pak are actually playing, after he was Pak's best bowler in the first Test

— Danyal Rasool (@Danny61000) August 2, 2026 To them it doesn't make sense why one of Pakistan's best bowlers was dropped by his own board when he was the one advocating for more matches in the longest format for his side. Another fan rounded back to his eight wickets in the first Test.

"Pakistan drop their best bowler from the 1st Test Mohammad Abbas due to conditions," they wrote . It is indeed hard to understand how pitch conditions would hinder someone who was able to snag a five -wicket haul in away conditions.

Pakistan drop their best bowler from the 1st Test Mohammad Abbas due to conditions pic.twitter.com/BDJGkljTV3

— Caribbean Cricket Podcast (@CaribCricket) August 2, 2026 Meanwhile, one fan was quick to point that this was simply because of who issues. "Unbelievable-drop your only proven wicket-taker; who has a track record of taking bucket-loads on slow turning tracks too. Pakistan cricket truly is a cesspit of egos and incompetence," they wrote .

Unbelievable-drop your only proven wicket-taker; who has a track record of taking bucket-loads on slow turning tracks too. Pakistan cricket truly is a cesspit of egos and incompetence. https://t.co/7Nf0a6Z2uV

— AmerCric 🏏 ✍️ (@Amermalik12) August 2, 2026 MORE: Jasprit Bumrah ruled out of Sri Lanka Tests! Front-runners to replace the Indian pacer listed

A self-inflicted wound in a familiar mould

There is a wearying predictability to this ...

Indexed and credited by AIPROPX. Originating outlet: Yahoo Sports. Open at source →