Writers see fit in Brewers trade for Skubal, but does it make sense?

With the Major League Baseball trade deadline coming up Aug. 3, the Milwaukee Brewers are sitting in an obvious playoff spot, have a loaded farm system and would theoretically be players for some of the top names seemingly available on the trade market.

But can we really expect 2026 to look different from other trade deadlines?

Count Mark Feinsand of MLB.com among those who believe the Brewers will indeed be "aggressive" at the deadline, but what does that look like?

ESPN writer Jeff Passan put together " 10 blockbuster deals that would rock the trade deadline " and arranged two deals involving a superstar going to Milwaukee. They would certainly count as aggressive.

Passan first proposed a deal that sends Detroit Tigers star left-hander Tarik Skubal to the Brewers for right-hander Logan Henderson, left fielder Josh Adamczewski and infielder Ricki Moneys. The latter two are among the more intriguing prospects in the Brewers organization, and Henderson is just graduating from prospect status into reliable major-league starter.

"Painful as it would be to give up a good rotation piece in Henderson, a surefire big leaguer in Adamczewski and a high-ceiling talent in Moneys, Milwaukee's farm depth allows this sort of deal," Passan wrote. "Models don't like it, but this isn't the time to listen to them. It's time to headline a rotation with Skubal and Misiorowski and let the rest take care of itself."

Adamczewski, 21, is one of the faster-rising prospects in all of minor-league baseball, currently at Class AA Biloxi, and Moneys, 17, is part of the Brewers' most recent international class but delivering impressive numbers in the Dominican Summer League. For a rental such as Skubal – he'll be a free agent after 2026 – the Brewers would be surrendering what looks like far too high a price in this theoretical deal, even for Henderson alone.

The 24-year-old has a 3.05 ERA and 0.94 WHIP this season in the big leagues, and is it a stretch to suggest he could perform within the same ballpark as Skubal over the final two months of the season? Never mind the five additional years of control thereafter. Never mind the significant additional losses of Adamczewski and Moneys.

Bob Nightengale of USA TODAY threw cold water on the idea of a Skubal-Brewers connection, saying, "They simply don't believe that Skubal will be the magic elixir for all their needs. They still need a power bat. They could use another late-inning reliever. They could use someone to step up and be that solid No. 3 starter."

Andy McCullough of The Athletic is among those not giving up on the Brewers-Skubal connection, though he admits it's a "probably not."

"Milwaukee built up its excellent farm system through discipline and diligence, and they may not deviate from that strategy," McCullough wrote. "(And the Tigers may just hold onto Skubal, anyway.) But, buddy, Skubal sure would look good beside Jacob Misiorowski at the top of the Brewers rotation, wouldn’t he? The franchise hasn’t reached the World Series since 1982. The team posted the best record in baseball last year and still got trounced by the Dodgers in the NLCS. Now might be the time to go for broke."

Jim Bowden of The Athletic also called Skubal an ideal fit for Milwaukee.

"The Brewers have the second-best team in the National League behind the Dodgers," he wrote. "Their chances of overtaking Los Angeles (or anyone else in the NL) to reach — and win — the World Series would go up significantly if they were able to acquire Skubal and team him with their ace, Jacob Misiorowski. I’m not sure if Detroit will trade Skubal, but I do know this: the Brewers have more than enough talent in their farm system to land him if they want to."

Skubal, the two-time reigning American League Cy Young award winner, has a 2.70 ERA this year in 15 starts. In eight starts since he returned from injury, he's got a 2.70 ERA and a 3.20 FIP (fielding independent pitching, more or less a "deserved" ERA based on certain factors the pitcher can control like homers allowed, walks, strikeouts and hit batters). Skubal has allowed eight homers and just seven walks with 65 strikeouts in 47 innings in those eight starts.

Henderson has had his own battles with injury this year, but he's thrown 38⅓ innings this season over his eight appearances with a 3.05 ERA and a 2.98 FIP. He has allowed five homers and seven walks to 47 strikeouts.

What about San Diego Padres closer Mason Miller?

Passan also proposed the San Diego Padres trading closer Mason Miller to the Brewers for Adamczewski, Braylon Payne, Bishop Letson and Sal Frelick.

Miller is under team control through 2030, hence a larger-volume package involving the team's first-round draft pick in 2024 in Payne (who's having an amazing season at Class High A Wisconsin) and arguably the top pitching prospect in the organization in Letson (who's having a so-so season at Biloxi), plus a big-leaguer in Frelick.

It's a little more tempting than the Skubal package, although Adamczewski might be doing so well this year that he's crossed into untouchable status. He has a .986 OPS across two minor-league levels this year, including a .907 mark in 30 games at Biloxi.

Miller, acquired by the Padres at least year's trade deadline, has a league-best 27 saves this year and a dazzling 80 strikeouts in 44 innings, with a 0.82 ERA. He's also gained notoriety as one of the hardest throwers in baseball history.

This article originally appeared on Milwaukee Journal Sentinel: Writers see fit in Brewers trade for Skubal, but does it make sense?

Indexed and credited by AIPROPX. Originating outlet: Yahoo Sports. Open at source →